top of page

Archived Comments

Jenna

April 09, 2020 at 11:37 PM UTC


Wasn’t her dress for the gala another similarity? The way it looked like it was made from noon beams.

Kinshuk

April 11, 2020 at 01:26 PM UTC


Kitty did mention the dress in her blog post above.

Jenna

April 13, 2020 at 10:37 PM UTC


Ohh, I see now, my bad😅 thanks! 😊

,
Jenna

April 09, 2020 at 11:38 PM UTC


*moon beams

Marietta

April 04, 2020 at 01:34 PM UTC


I actually missed the ring similarities. I wasn’t reading the story to look for any more similarities. I was just enjoying the story. I’m so grateful the parents were redeemed, though. I loved the dress and the scenes it figured in (Cheshire cat grin), and I loved the re-introduction of the real signet ring. I thought it was odd that Hazel’s mother was stronger than her husband, but not considered the Adept. But it makes sense if they down played her role and allowed him to be a kind of decoy to protect her. And considering what they did to Hazel to give her a perspective they felt she needed, it makes sense they would also make this deception as a protective strategy, especially when they saw how Wizards were behaving so badly politically. Now, we just need to uncover a murder plot on her parents to explain their sudden deaths….

Jocelyn Malone

April 04, 2020 at 02:48 AM UTC


I actually had an easier time seeing the hints in this one (I saw a bit in the first, but these ones just jumped out at me more, I guess). And…I actually remembered where the real ring probably was. Something about the specificity of the description on the necklace, and how it was mentioned that she had it on every time we saw the little girl, tipped my attention. But I definitely still enjoyed how it played out!

Chloey

April 03, 2020 at 11:02 PM UTC


I hope to have a lot of similarities in book 3, because it would be that BAM WHAT!?!? You know from Liv and Maddie! Before it got discontinued

Elsie

April 03, 2020 at 10:29 PM UTC


Yes!! That was amazing to see how it all goes together!

Donkeyskin: The Similarities, Part II

Magic Redeemed has been out for a while now, but I still need to warn you all this is a huge, massive, spoil-filled post! So if you haven’t read Magic Redeemed, yet, don’t read this! Now, with that warning out of the way, let’s begin!


There were a couple of smaller pieces of Donkeyskin that I threaded into Magic Redeemed–several of you have already called out the sparkly, silver dress, which, yes, I designed after the second dress Gross King orders for his daughter–but the two biggest things I focused in on were Hazel’s signet ring/Princess Donkeyskin’s ring, and the parents, version 2.0.


Let’s start with the ring!

In the original story, the princess brings her dresses, and some of her royal jewelry with her when she’s on the run. Because she’s pretty conniving, when the Prince declares himself heartbroken and says he’ll only eat if it’s a cake made by her, donkeyskin drops her ring in the batter and cooks it into the cake. The pervy prince almost swallows it, but for him it’s the confirmation he needed. Donkeyskin is indeed the beautiful girl he peeped on.


Frankly, to me that sounded dead boring, and a waste of a good twist.

I like magic battles and fights in my books, so I decided to take ring in a different direction, and make it something Hazel needed to find, and instead of plunking it a cake, she goes through a lot of pain–and even breaks into a magical vault/bank–to get it. However, l kept it as the end all ‘proof of being who she says she is’ in order to pay homage to the original fairy tale. If Hazel has the ring, she has proof she’s the Adept–just as Donkeyskin slipping the prince the ring was the signal of who she was.

But instead of making the whole ring thing super obvious where everyone knows about it, I hid the ring in plain sight in Book 1 because–unlike the original story–I wanted it to be a real surprise to Hazel and you Champions when she found the real ring!


If you squint you can also see the similarities in the ring’s role–Prince Pervert says he’ll only marry the girl who can wear the ring, and in the end the House will only accept the Adept who has the ring. Killian doesn’t really play a role in the part of the story, except in that Rupert is right and he kicks Hazel out because he knows she can get her House back.

Next, Magic Redeemed gave Hazel’s parents their opportunity for a redemption arc.


OOOOHHHH, pulled that one over on you, didn’t I?? (Right?? Please say right!)


Actually, I’m aware this is possibly the twist you guys saw coming. I’m not overly fond of fairytales that constantly turn the parents into the bad guys. I’ve done some that way, but whenever possible I like to avoid it–and Donkeyskin is, weirdly enough, the perfect book to have the parents’ restored in, because Gross King in the original story actually gets a redemption moment when, at the end of the story, he attends Donkeyskin’s wedding and apologizes for everything he did.


Since both of Hazel’s parents were dead, Hazel couldn’t get a moment of physical closure, but I still wanted to give her that emotional closure that would assure her that her parents really were the kind, good people she thought they were. I also wanted this to be a defining moment for Hazel, because her parents essentially back up her decisions, which has a big impact on her actions in the future.


The thread of their redemption arc actually begins before Hazel even gets a hint of what they’d done to her. I designed this trilogy knowing that when Hazel’s parents called her in the very first scene of Book 1, they were asking her to meet them at the Curia Cloisters so they could tell her everything, and reveal to her the truth of her stunted magic. But I wanted to use Book 1 & Book 2 to draw out growth in Hazel–she learns a lot about making her own decisions–and to fulfill the icky parents’ end of the bargain, so I needed to hide the truth of their actions from you readers as well.


So, what do you think, Champions? 😉 Did you see any of the other small hints of Donkeyskin  I glossed over in book 2?

Related Posts

See All

Comments


Hey Champions! Welcome to the new website! Please be patient as my web designer finishes connecting everything.